Starring Peter Jackson, Jeffrey Thomas, Costa Botes, Marguerite Hurst, Leonard Maltin, Johnny Morris, Sam Neill, John O’Shea, Lindsay Shelton, Harvey Weinstein, Thomas Robins, Beatrice Ashton, Peter Corrigan, Sarah McLeod
Directed by Peter Jackson & Costa Botes
Expectations: High. I love this.
First Peter Jackson crafts the goriest film of all time, and then he follows it up with an Oscar-nominated indie drama. So what does he follow that up with? An incredibly enlightening documentary about a largely unknown figure in the history of film, that’s what. Forgotten Silver chronicles the quest of Peter Jackson and Costa Botes to uncover the legend of late New Zealand filmmaker Colin McKenzie, probably the most important figure in early film history.
Ideally, it’d be best to see Forgotten Silver with no knowledge that it isn’t real, because directors Peter Jackson and Costa Botes have pulled off one hell of a sustained illusion. I did notice one overt clue for knowledgeable film fans (a Russian interviewee named “Alexandra Nevsky”), but even if you miss that one it’d be hard not to miss just how over-the-top and wild the life of Colin McKenzie is made out to be. For instance, after some stories of how Colin built his first camera onto his bicycle (and therefore created the first tracking shot), we’re told that he also made his own film stock, with an emulsion layer made of egg whites. CUT TO: a newspaper clipping that reads: “2000 Eggs Stolen.”
I will add a small disclaimer at this point to say that if you intend to see the film, it would be much more enjoyable to discover its joys for yourself instead of reading my thoughts on them.
The quality of the documentary filming is so well-carried out that it both serves as a fantastic doc and as a perfect straight-faced comedy. The comedic beats are unexpected and hilarious, but it would also be just as easy for a more naive person to buy into it, especially one who isn’t too deep into their love of film. When the film first aired on New Zealand TV (which it was produced for), it supposedly fooled many who saw it. This is a testament to how spot-on McKenzie’s “found” footage (filmed by Peter Jackson) is, perfectly capturing the silent era and even early sound-recording techniques. I kind of said it all in that previous sentence, but the skill to recreate films of the era is quite impressive. In order for the documentary to work, the footage had to be believable as something that was found in a trunk from 90 years ago, and this footage is that to a T.
In order to fund his biblical passion project Salome, McKenzie had to pay the bills by directing the films of a silent comedian, Stan the Man. Only thing is: Stan the Man wasn’t that funny. He was a fifth-rate Buster Keaton at best, but during the filming of his first short, a little girl wandered into the frame and told Stan the Man he wasn’t that funny. This was the moment that changed the course of Stan’s (and McKenzie’s) career, as the camera captured Stan hitting the kid in response to her insult. When the film screened for an audience, it was the only moment that received a laugh, so Stan the Man insisted that they were onto something and must include this “violence against the innocent” in all of their films. It became his running gag, and it’s brilliantly funny in the context of the doc. I love a good pie to the face, perhaps more than most people, but to see Stan the Man slap a few into people’s faces and then dance around and mug for the camera is priceless.
The film also boasts notable interviews from people such as Leonard Maltin and Harvey Weinstein, which adds a Hollywood credibility to the film that Jackson alone could not at the time. Jackson is arguably the most believable interviewee, though, telling us about McKenzie’s life and films with true passion and a completely straight face. Especially if you’ve seen him in any of the behind-the-scenes material on the DVDs of his later films, he acts with the same style and it becomes instantly believable.
If you love classic films and fake documentaries, then you’ll love Forgotten Silver. It may be a small footnote in Peter Jackson’s gory, fantastic career, but it’s hilarious and well-worth your time.
Ahh, the only Peter Jackson film I haven’t seen yet – because I’ve been unable to locate it legitimately here in Australia. Amazon might be my friend, I think….
I wish people would make more of these kind of films and release them to the public as a joke, it really makes me laugh that so many people were taken in by it!
Nice work Will!
Ah man, you should definitely track it down. I don’t know about its Region 4 status, but it had a good Region 1 release with nice extras (commentary, making of) a few years back. It’s out of print, but if you can play R1 discs and you’re really into Peter Jackson, I’d say it’s well worth it.
I would fully support more people making these kinds of switcheroo movies that might fool some people. This one is so well-done it’s easy to believe that people were taken by it, but it’s also so outlandish at times that I can’t believe anyone believed it! Hope you get a chance to see it.