Spiritual Kung Fu (1978)

Spiritual-Kung-Fu-001Spiritual Kung Fu [拳精] (1978)
AKA Karate Ghostbuster

Starring Jackie Chan, James Tin Jun, Mo Man-Sau, Li Tong-Chun, Lee Kwan, Dean Shek Tin, Ko Keung, Lee Hoi-Lung, Lee Man-Tai, Wang Kuang-Yu, Wong Ching

Directed by Lo Wei

Expectations: Moderate.

twostar


Lo Wei’s Spiritual Kung Fu may have been released to the public just a month and a half after Drunken Master blew up the Hong Kong box office, but it was made well-before as an answer to Half a Loaf of Kung Fu, Chen Chi-Hwa’s kung fu comedy starring Jackie Chan. After many requests from Jackie to allow him to include comedy in his films, Lo Wei finally relented and let Jackie and Chen make Half a Loaf of Kung Fu. But upon seeing the finished film, Lo was furious and he shelved the film (until 1980). He didn’t find it funny at all, and he made Spiritual Kung Fu in order to show Jackie what a real kung fu comedy should be like. Spiritual Kung Fu lucked out being released after Drunken Master, because at that point the public craved anything Jackie Chan. It gave this film box office receipts that came close to equaling those of Snake in the Eagle’s Shadow, and which also bested many Shaw Brothers films destined to be memorable classics (such as The Five Venoms & Crippled Avengers).

So I suppose knowing all that, the big question about Spiritual Kung Fu hangs around its comedy. Is it funny? Do the laughs feel similar to the kung fu comedy of the two Jackie Chan/Yuen Woo-Ping collaborations? The answer is a resounding NO! There’s a reason why Lo Wei wasn’t known as a comedy director. The first half of the film goes hard into Lo’s idea of comedy, with things like Jackie stuffing random animals down his pants (including a snake that finds “a nice, dark place to call home,” if you know what I mean!), punishments that include writing calligraphy with a gigantic brush, a mischievous ghost that farts in a monk’s face, and Jackie pissing on the ghosts as they shrink and try to hide in a corner. You get the idea; the comedy is really low-brow. It’s kind of interesting to watch because you never know what’s coming next, but it’s a stretch to call it funny. That being said, I can imagine children getting more laughs out of it than I did, but there are better films to get your children laughing.

spiritualkungfu_5And what sets Spiritual Kung Fu back even more is that after half of the movie focuses on this comedy, it largely disappears for the second half of the film. That might sound like a good thing, as it might make way for awesome kung fu battles, but that sadly isn’t the case. The heretofore sub-plot involving the stolen Shaolin Seven Deadly Fists manual and its lost-for-centuries counterpart, the Essence of the Five Fists manual, takes control of the film and we never look back. But even this traditionally plotted kung fu stuff is kind of boring, and largely slave to Lo Wei’s desires to do things like they used to be done. So when Jackie learns the Essence of the Five Fists style from the ghosts inside the manual, we only see a couple of brief sparring matches between him and the ghosts and then suddenly he’s a master. It’s very similar to how the old school Shaw Brothers films handled training. This reinforces my desire to see everything in chronological order, as while something like this might fly in the early days of Jackie Chan’s career, it’s almost depressing to watch after Drunken Master. I got a good handle on the frustration that must have gone through Jackie’s mind while making these films for Lo Wei.

But no matter what, I did enjoy the kung fu ghosts, perhaps more than I should have. They arrive on a comet that lands in the Shaolin library, and they immediately start causing trouble (and eventually farting in that monk’s face). They wear long red wigs and white leotard bodysuits with tutus and white face paint. And just about every time they’re on-screen, they are accompanied by a bubbling synth bass groove that I enjoyed quite a bit. It’s a stretch to call it music, but it evokes something of an otherworldly style and feeling. The ghosts are a comical bunch, for sure, but sadly I liked them more in theory than in practice. They never get a real chance to shine. I’m sure Lo was glad to finally have a hit film with Jackie, but I have to wonder if he actually thought this was a good kung fu comedy after seeing what Jackie had achieved with Yuen Woo-Ping. I imagine not, given what happened when Jackie returned to make the final film of his contract with Lo Wei… but that’s a story for another review.

spiritualkungfu_3Another major failing point is that there’s a sad lack of fights in this film, especially in the first half. The first legitimate fight with Jackie isn’t until 46 minutes in, once again featuring his fun snake-style fighting seen in many previous films. It’s not a great fight by any means, but in this movie it’s fun and much appreciated after so long without much in the way of martial arts — spiritual or otherwise. There are more fights as the film moves towards the conclusion, with two big ones between Jackie and James Tin Jun coming almost back-to-back. While the choreography is technically sound and the movements are well-performed, after the Seasonal films it’s just hard to get excited by what’s on offer here. If we try to forget those films and remember that this was made prior to them, they’re more pleasing. The fights aren’t on par with some of the stuff seen in Snake and Crane Arts of Shaolin, but they are near the top end of the Lo Wei-produced Jackie Chan films. That being said, they’re also kind of boring and without much innovation. Jackie does a few good acrobatic moves, but the fights are merely fights, unlike later Jackie fights where it feels like there’s an entire story being told through the choreography. The tale of the battle, so to speak. In any case, Jackie’s battle to leave Shaolin (AKA the Eighteen Monks’ Test) is a good one, and easily the most memorable thing about this movie besides the ghost farts.

spiritualkungfu_4Even through my disappointment and the malaise that set in while watching Spiritual Kung Fu, I did still enjoy it. It’s not one I’d reach for again any time soon, but it’s got a few moments sprinkled throughout that are unique enough to be memorable. I like the idea of ghosts in kung fu movies, bringing something supernatural to the genre, but Spiritual Kung Fu definitely does not have the ghosts putting their best ectoplasm forward.

Next up in this chronological journey through the films of Jackie Chan is Jackie’s first crack at directing, the 1979 film The Fearless Hyena!

2 comments to Spiritual Kung Fu (1978)

  • “spiritual king-fu” seems to be a tautology, a lot like “erotic porn” or “stupid Twilight novels”.

    But that “ghostbusters” poster is a gem. If I needed kung-fu ass-kicking of the spirit world, Chan would be at the top of my speed-dial!!!

    • Most kung fu does have a spiritual element, but the title refers more to the ghosts than anything else. So I guess it would’ve been better titled Supernatural Kung Fu. It looks like the actual Chinese characters don’t translate to anything terribly close to Spiritual Kung Fu, so it’s possible that the word Spiritual was used in the English title because of the success of Lau Kar-Leung’s 1975 movie The Spiritual Boxer. But I’m just spitballin’, I have no clue really.

      I do like that Ghostbusters poster!

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.