Uncle Jasper reviews: Challenge of the Masters (1976)

Challenge of the Masters [陸阿采與黃飛鴻] (1976)

Starring Gordon Liu Chia-Hui, Chen Kuan-Tai, Lau Kar-Leung, Kong Yeung, Wong Yu, Lau Kar Wing, Lily Li Li-Li, Fung Hak-On

Directed By Lau Kar-Leung


I was a little nervous on revisiting Challenge of the Masters after such a long time in-between viewings of it. It’s a film that I have a long history with since copying it off of a well-worn VHS copy back during the infancy of Blockbuster Video. Yeah, that’s how we did shit back in the days before digital distribution, instant streaming, and the rise of the World Wide Web. Back then, I had no idea what the deal with the Shaw Brothers was. I recognized Gordon Liu in a couple of other films, but directors, actors, and choreographers meant very little to me at the time. I just knew that when I saw that big, fat SB shield accompanied by the thundering fanfare, it was going to be a higher grade kung fu film than I was used to getting. Challenge of the Masters wound up becoming my favorite martial arts film of the Shaw Bros studios. Now revisiting it 17 years later, I can safely say that is an accolade which still stands.

The film is an “origin story” of sorts to the character of Wong Fei-Hung, whom Gordon Liu plays masterfully here. Jet Li did such a good job of making him seem like a righteous and invincible badass in the Once Upon a Time in China series, that it may come as a shock here to find the character portrayed as a clumsy, unsophisticated, buffoon of sorts, prone to bouts of self-pity and frequent temper tantrums. This is all for the sake of the film however, as Challenge of the Masters presents the ultimate journey in martial arts cinema by taking the “unteachable” teenage Fei-Hung and details his transformation into China’s most well-known folk hero.

The film’s plot centers around rival kung fu schools, and their quest for notoriety in the martial world through their participation in the pao competition, a no-holds-barred sport where a bunch of batons are fired into the sky whereupon the schools make a mad grab to collect as many as they can. It comes off as a cross between European rugby and schoolyard jungle ball. The competition is both fun and action packed, as mobs of kung fu students hurl themselves into the air and at each other in order to collect as many batons as possible.

That’s all gravy in this reviewer’s eye however, as Challenge of the Masters finest moments swirl around the meticulous and delicate relationship between Fei-Hung and his revered teacher Lu Ah-Tsai, played to absolute perfection by Chen Kuan-Tai. This relationship is definitely a product of director Lau Kar-Leung’s watchful eye, who made a point of bringing real kung fu, in both its physical and philosophical forms to audiences worldwide. Every moment of Fei-Hung’s training is absolutely compelling, as Ah-Tsai’s teachings resonate not only during the training scenes themselves, but throughout the rest of the film as well. I’d go as far as to say that this is the definitive teacher / student relationship in martial arts cinema, and I wouldn’t even think twice about it.

The training itself is both grueling and brilliant in its economy as Lau Kar-Leung manages to not only squeeze two years of practice into about twenty minutes of screen time, but also makes it completely believable. He quickly cuts the brash and overeager Fei-Hung down to size with weeks of arduous stances and tedious basic footwork patterns. It’s the typical stuff you’ve seen in hundreds of kung fu films before, but never as raw and undiluted as you will see here, with a reclining Ah-Tsai puffing away on his pipe while literally beating the proper stances out of Fei-Hung with a long bamboo pole. Fei-Hung definitely has his moments of cockiness and from time to time challenges his venerable master, going as far as ambushing a relaxed Ah-Tsai, who is reading a book. The older master, without batting an eye, spins himself around and slaps Fei-Hung away with the manuscript before continuing his reading.

After months of staff training, in which Fei-Hung must focus intently on the tip of the pole while drawing miniscule circles around ceramic teacups without breaking them, Ah-Tsai takes a brief moment to drop a philosophical nugget on his now-cultured student. He mentions that after two years of training in the martial arts you will feel like you have learned everything, after twenty however, you will feel that you really know nothing. A life in the martial arts means endless discovery. Even a master can learn from the student. The student absorbs this grain of wisdom and in a climactic final test amidst pouring rain, manages to snatch the tobacco pipe from his master’s hands, thus completing his training.

I know that more often than not, people consider martial arts actors “martial artists” first and “actors” a distant second. But I challenge anybody to make that same criticism of Gordon Liu in this film (even more remarkable when you consider it was his first starring role). When he descends from that mountain, his belly full of knowledge, and mourns the grave of a deceased brother an old friend notices him and begins staring. A stoic and transformed Fei-Hung asks, “What’s wrong, don’t you recognize me?” to which the friend replies “Yes. But you look… different.” The transformation is complete. The clumsy teenager is now a master himself, carrying himself with so much dignity and righteousness that even old friends have trouble recognizing him.

Director Lau Kar-Leung plays the film’s main villain, a murderous criminal from the north who has no qualms whatsoever about kicking respected masters to death with iron-tipped boots. When the virtuous Wong Fei-Hung finally confronts the man, he easily beats him with his newfound long-pole skills. The cowering killer retreats to a bamboo thicket, where a surprised Fei-Hung suddenly has trouble utilizing his sweeping staff techniques. The staff is no longer useful and must be discarded… a martial artist is always learning indeed. Even in the heat of battle his teacher’s wisdom rings true.

4 comments to Uncle Jasper reviews: Challenge of the Masters (1976)

  • Awesome review for an awesome movie. It’d been so long since I’d seen this I barely remembered anything except for the training sequence, which is hands down one of the best scenes of its kind.

    Lau Kar-Leung is so awesome as the villain too, I’ve always liked him and he’s phenomenal in this. His directing and the editing of the fights are even more impressive and totally reminds me why he’s one of my favorite kung fu directors.

    Plus by casting the Shaw Bros. veteran Chen Kuan-Tai as the master to teach the noob Gordon Liu, you get a interesting symbolic dynamic for where the Shaw Bros. studios went after this, as Gordon Liu became their big star and Chen Kuan-Tai left to pursue other things (and later returned).

  • Uncle Jasper

    Lots of good points you made here. I think it’s movies like this that really make Lau Kar-Leung stand apart from other directors in the Shaw Studios. A director like Chang Cheh can make a really fun martial arts film, but LKL’s movies always bring with them an attempt to teach a genuine understanding of the martial arts. I think in terms of spirit and passion they are more honest and true than Chang Cheh’s films.

    Not to say they are better in any way, but LKL adds credence and authenticity to a lot of things that other directors would usually choose to ignore. His character in the film is a traveler from the north, and he actually uses a lot of northern styles in his choreography that do a great job contrasting the southern Hung Gar styles of Wong Fei-Hung and Lu Ah-Tsai. I realize that these are things that your average filmgoer won’t care about, but people with a real interest in kung fu will pick up on this stuff and find that it really adds to the realism.

    I’m glad you brought up different generations of Shaw Bros. actors as well. As it really was around this time that you saw a changing of the guard. The Ti Lung / David Chiang combo that pulled the Shaw Bros. along through the late 60s / early 70s would fall away giving rise to the venoms films. Great point!

    • Yeah Lau Kar-Leung’s movies definitely have a martial arts grounding that a lot of other Shaw Bros do not have. Chang Cheh’s movies have more of a fun atmosphere to them. This is another reason why the Shaw Studios were so awesome, because on the surface the films may be similar looking, but thanks to a handful of really talented directors you get a whole range of films.

  • Great review. I really liked the point you made about Gordon Liu’s acting.

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!