Broken Embraces (2009)

Broken Embraces [Los abrazos rotos] (2009)

Starring Penélope Cruz, Blanca Portillo, Lluís Homar, Lola Dueñas, Ángela Molina, Rossy de Palma

Directed by Pedro Almodóvar

Expectations: Very high.


Pedro Almodovar is quickly becoming one of my favorite writer/directors. This is the third film I’ve seen from him and he continues to amaze me. There is a power in his words and images that is hard to find in modern cinema. The story of Broken Embraces deals primarily with a retired film director (Lluís Homar) who has gone blind. The film also flashes back 14 years to the character of Lena (Penelope Cruz), a secretary for a wealthy businessman who aspires to be an actress. The film unfolds at a slow but interesting pace, gradually intertwining the two stories with skill.

The acting all around is excellent with Penelope Cruz and Lluís Homar leading the charge. The characters they play feel like real people, full of emotions and desire. The film jumps around in time a lot, but thanks to the wonderful performances this is never a problem. The acting reflects the subtle passage of time and you can quickly grasp where the character is at the current moment in relation to what you know of the character prior. This kind of free time structure can so easily work against a film, but Almodovar plays it with skill and it helps him tell a more interesting story.

Of the three Almodovar pictures I’ve seen (Talk to Her and Volver being the other two) this is by far the least overtly sexual. It was borderline mundane in that way, where I have come to expect edgy, frank and real depictions and discussions of the sexual nature of humans. That is not to say that Broken Embraces is devoid of sexuality, in fact it flows and pulses with sexual energy but it is more reserved and subtle than what I expected. I don’t mean this to sound like a complaint though, as the subtle nature of the script was perfect for this story and worked very well on-screen.

Almodovar has said that this film is his love letter to filmmaking, but it is done in such a way where it isn’t immediately clear that’s what he’s doing. Even after the film ended I was slightly puzzled about it because I felt that there was more homage to the craft in Talk to Her than this. After a couple of days of revisiting it in my mind though, I realize now how deep it runs throughout the film. Editing is one of the most important and misunderstood aspects of the filmmaking process, and it is editing here that is the key point. Broken Embraces seeks to impart how important editing is to the final product, both in plot points and in actual practice. This is one of the best edited works of 2009, running a close second to Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds.

Almodovar is by far my favorite visual filmmaker working today. I am constantly amazed by how well thought out and beautiful his shots and framing are. Not a single shot is wasted in this film, every one perfectly composed. A pile of torn photos, a curtain, even an x-ray of an arm all look beautiful and distinct through Almodovar’s lens. Every frame is exploding with a painter’s palette of colors, but nothing seems flashy about his style. That’s the amazing thing. It’s easy to be flashy and have people flock to your films, but to be stylish without overusing flash is brilliant.

I’ve heard that his earlier films have a different tone and style (supposedly more flashy and less mature) than the later-period movies that I have seen. I might be way off base here, but ever since I saw my first Almodovar film I’ve felt that he is a kindred spirit to Quentin Tarantino. Quentin is definitely flashier and he “borrows” too much, but both directors share such an unabashed love of the art and language of cinema that I can’t help but think of them in a similar space. I can’t be the only one to think this though, as last year’s foreign language Oscar was presented by none other than both Almodovar and Tarantino.

I can’t recommend this movie or Pedro Almodovar enough. It is auteurs like him that have made me passionate about film. He is reason enough to watch foreign films if you aren’t already doing so. I can’t wait to experience more of his films.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bN0SlBE8yGQ

10 comments to Broken Embraces (2009)

  • Uncle Jasper

    Holy shit. This is a good review. Very interested in checking this one out now.

    • Thanks, man. Have you seen any of his movies? He has such a strong personal style and it just seems to click with me. There’s some really well-shot bullfighting scenes in Talk to Her that you would enjoy too.

      • Uncle Jasper

        I have heard of him by name only, but have yet to have seen any of his films. Your review got me super excited about this one though, it reminds me of the old Cahiers du cinéma reviews I was really into reading when I first got into film. Extremely well done.

        • Man, you are too kind. Thanks. I’ll have to back up that compliment with a serious French New Wave review. Hope you like the film as much as the review. I worked super hard on this one to make sure I did it justice, so I’m glad that it paid off. Just wait till my Ghoulies review though! hahaha

  • This is an excellent piece of analysis. I haven’t seen this film but I have seen Volver (twice), which I liked very, very much.So I might give this one a try sometime.

    • Thanks! Yeah if you liked Volver, you will probably enjoy this also. I still can’t decide which of the three Almodovar films I’ve seen that I like the most. I think it might be Volver, but this one is pretty damn good. Talk to Her is quite impressive as well.

  • This is probably my favorite movie from 2009. Almodovar is such a brilliant filmmaker.

    I’ve also seen three of his movies (this, Volver, and All About My Mother). Broken Embraces is my favorite, but I can’t wait to see more of his movies.

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!