Stephen reviews: Judge (1991)

JUDGE_1Judge [闇の司法官ジャッジ Yami no Shihosha Judge] (1991)
AKA Magistrate of Darkness: Judge

Starring Kaneto Shiozawa, Keiko Yamamoto, Miki Ito, Shinya Ohtaki, Tomomichi Nishimura, Daisuke Gouri

Directed by Hiroshi Negishi


Often it’s nice to go into a film with no idea what you’re about to watch, and Judge was one of those films that surprised me precisely because I didn’t know what it was. It gave me a sense of mystery and curiosity that would have been shattered if I’d heard about it before. In that sense, I suppose this review is going to ruin things for you, as you might enjoy this film best with as little knowledge as I had. But before you decide to read no further, you should know that the film is only average, and perhaps not worth such lofty concerns. It has its moments of fun, but there’s nothing that makes this some kind of must-see experience. Now on to the explaining.

It starts off with a business man in a swampy jungle, running away from a much more appropriately attired guy with a sniper rifle. This opening is where my expectations were thrown for a loop. It looked like I was diving into one of those films about some rich guy wanting to hunt the ultimate prey. So when it introduces us to the bumbling Ohma, I was expecting him to get dragged into a jungle for sport, only to prove that under his fumbling exterior were stores of unexpected resourcefulness. Obviously, this didn’t quite happen.

JUDGE_2Though I was right that Ohma’s incompetent demeanor is just a facade. But he’s not just some guy that knows more than he lets on. He’s actually a judge of darkness. When someone is murdered and doesn’t get justice, Ohma uses dark magic to track down the murderer and gives them the punishment they deserve. So the film is a dark magic revenge story instead of a man on the run story.

This little twist probably gave me a higher enjoyment from the film than it deserved, but it’s those times when a film surprises you that are the most enjoyable, so all I can say is that I had fun with it. That may have been countered by the scratched-up DVD Netflix sent me, though. The damn thing kept skipping around and crashing every DVD player I have set up. It even skipped the final confrontation entirely, jumping me to the conclusion without knowing what happened, forcing me to rewind and piece together what I could from the jittery disc. This obviously doesn’t make the film itself any worse, but it did color my experience of it.

JUDGE_3I wonder if I would have enjoyed the end of the film more had I been able to watch it properly, but for the most part I think not. The more I think about it, the more I realize that the end stumbled into a very awkwardly concluded battle. That final confrontation veers away from the unstoppable dark magic, and swings into a bizarre legal argument in front of the gods. You see, the plot takes another twist half way through the film when the lawyer shows up. Now Ohma has to get through the magical defense attorney in order to get revenge for the deceased.

This actually worked pretty well at first, as the battle was less one of legal debate and more of a showdown between two dark wizards hurling demons and explosions at each other. This battle didn’t have the creativity or unique tone that the best dark magic films do, but it did have a pair of flying magic gloves that were pretty damn awesome. The film manages to pull off a pretty exciting showdown in the mountains between the two wizards, and it’s made all the weirder by the legal terminology that they throw around with their spells.

JUDGE_4Where the film started to fall apart was immediately after this battle. That’s when they get summoned into the spirit world to argue their cases before a council of gods who will decide the victor. It’s kinda weak on its own, and the conclusion feels really tacked on. It’s as if the director wanted to just get this boring legal battle over with even more than I did, and he just threw on a cheap and convenient ending to wrap it all up.

Another problem the film had was a lack of focus. It spends so much time setting up Ohma and showing what he does that the film is halfway done by the time he gets to the real villain (who has some of the weirdest looking eyes I’ve ever seen in an anime). It left me feeling a bit lost as to where the film was going and what its point was, but it never managed to make Ohma’s character or his relationship with his girlfriend feel anything more than superficial.

Certainly the film could have been a lot better, but in the end I had enough fun to justify watching it, even with that damn scratched-up disc. The visuals were pretty cool, the plot was twisty enough to keep me interested, and some of the action was fairly memorable. So give it a whirl if black magic is your thing. It just might work for you.

No trailer, I’m afraid, but I did find this odd little death scene.

3 comments to Stephen reviews: Judge (1991)

  • This is another of those movies I had on VHS, but I don’t know that I ever watched it. I probably should have given my love of black magic!

  • Stephen

    Aw, that’s a shame. It was pretty decent, and I imagine a black magic fan would get at least a moderate amount of entertainment from it.

    • At least visually, it looks like a lot of fun.

      My unspoken tradition since starting SE is to watch and review some black magic films every October, but this year many things have gotten in my way of achieving that goal. Perhaps with some good fortune I’ll be able to deliver some before the end of the month. If nothing else, I’m glad you got to one!

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!