Stephen reviews: All Star Superman (2011)

1699114Starring James Denton, Christina Hendricks, Anthony Lapaglia, Edward Asner, Alexis Denisof, Steve Blum, John DiMaggio, Robin Atkin Downes, Michael Gough, Matthew Gray Gubler

Directed by Sam Liu


Another comic book adaptation, All Star Superman also carries over the visual style of its original artists, this time Frank Quitely and Jamie Grant. The look isn’t as striking as Public Enemies, but it’s still noticeable. They improved the animation a bit, but not so much the CG. This give and take makes it balance out about the same.

The film is a throwback to the olden days of comic books. All the crazy plot devices from comic’s Golden Age are brought back without shame, and that’s exactly how you’ll need to take this film. It’s full of harebrained events like an army of reptile monsters from the center of the Earth, Superman’s house key which was carved from a dwarf star and weighs half a million tons, or the audio book reader that Lex Luthor uses to dig a tunnel out of prison by reciting literature at incredibly high-pitched frequencies. Anyone who loves the good ol’ days of comic books will find tons to love about this film.

If this kind of implausible campy fun makes your eyes roll, however, then you aren’t going to enjoy this much. But I say to those people: Superman is an alien who conveniently looks exactly like a human and gains incredible superpowers from sunbathing. How can you whine about having a serious storyline when his entire concept is absurd? This film imagines the wild excesses of the Golden Age as half homage, half modernization, half philosophical musing, and a hefty dollop of parody. Nowhere outside of an anthology of old comic books will you find so many improbable plot devices in one spot than here.

allstarsuperman_2All of the wild ideas do come across as scattered and unrelated, though. The film plays out more as a series of episodes than a single story arc. Superman does a lot of weird stuff like creating miniature stars to feed his pet sun-eater, making a potion that gives Lois superpowers for a day, and solving the unsolvable riddle of the sphinx. Oh wait, I mean the ULTRA-SPHINX. ‘Cuz that’s so much cooler than a regular sphinx. But the plot has more cohesion than it first appears. All of those things come back into play for the grand finale. I would argue the ultra-sphinx’s riddle to be more important than the others. Superman’s answer is not just some random side-story. I think it reflects the final climax of the film, and Superman’s relationship with Lex Luthor.

There’s a lot more thought going into these events than is immediately apparent. Even the title itself is more appropriate to the plot than at first glance. Stars, the sun in specific, tie into the plot in a big way. At the beginning of the film, Superman gets a little too close to the sun and absorbs too much energy. It makes him even more powerful than before, but that power is more than he can handle, and his cells start to self-destruct from all that energy. Superman is dying. The film is less an action/adventure tale than it is a character study of the Man of Steel in his final days.

allstarsuperman_3

That character is one of calm acceptance. In fact, Supes is not very concerned about much of anything. The dude is as chill as his own ice-breath. Even when some Kryptonians show up and break the moon, his reaction doesn’t have much emotion. I can understand that when it’s almost impossible to hurt a guy, he might stop worrying about stuff, but I couldn’t help thinking they took it a bit too far. Especially since the plot is a rather scattered collection of events. The combination winds up making the film go about as fast as water flows uphill. There’s a lot to entertain, but there doesn’t seem to be any connecting thread until the end, and even that connection requires some contemplation. You’ll spend most of your time wondering where the hell this film is going.

allstarsuperman_4As with most other animated DC films, All Star Superman bolsters up the action scenes, taking what might be a page or two in the comic and extending it into an elaborate action piece. Usually this is good. You need to use the strengths of your medium to their fullest, and the extra excitement is very necessary for such a meandering film as this. But one of the scenes — when Parasite goes on a rampage — turns into another flaw. Mainly because Superman himself is standing on the sidelines. Come on Supes, stop dithering around pretending to be Clark Kent and get a move on! Parasite is sucking the life out of people. Do something! This time the extra action made Superman’s laid back attitude seem like complete disinterest.

So the film does have a few problems. I still had a good time with it, though. People who want a modern, no-nonsense, non-camp superhero action film are going to be very disappointed, but if you are a fan of the bygone era of comic books that were all about pure, unrestricted fun, then there’s a lot to love about this movie, even if it does stumble a few times along the way. Besides, it’s not like those old comics never stumbled either. So take Superman’s attitude. Just sit back, let it roll on by, and enjoy the fun for what it is.

4 comments to Stephen reviews: All Star Superman (2011)

  • Also, the correct answer to the Ultra-Sphinx’s riddle is that the two cannot exist in the same universe. If there is one, there cannot be the other. I found that the ridiculousness of the events did lend more to parody than to serious story, I found myself laughing out loud many times during the runtime, especially the random joke of Olsen’s outfit.

  • “It’s full of harebrained events like an army of reptile monsters from the center of the Earth, Superman’s house key which was carved from a dwarf star and weighs half a million tons, or the audio book reader that Lex Luthor uses to dig a tunnel out of prison by reciting literature at incredibly high-pitched frequencies.”

    OH MY GOD. Are there comic fans that don’t like stuff like this? I didn’t think it was possible to sell me on these animated DC movies (because they don’t appeal to me visually at all), but these things you list sound INCREDIBLE! I love a good realistic superhero tale, but I think Superman lends himself well to the real over-the-top stuff.

    Y’know, the closer we get to Man of Steel, the more disappointed I think I’m going to be. I’ve tried not to see anything since the first trailer last year, but I have a suspicion that this Superman won’t be as fun and grand. We’ll see.

    • Stephen

      Sadly there are. This receives more hate than the other DC films. Looking at the Amazon reviews, most of the other Superman movies have a very top heavy distribution, with lots of five star, a bunch of four star, a few three star and only a couple bad reviews. This one has a much more even distribution, though. Maybe it’s the times we live in. People want a believable story these days, even from their superheroes.

      Somehow I had a feeling if any of these animated films would interest you it would be this one. More so than any of the others, this felt like watching a comic book. It’s like taking orange juice concentrate, the stuff you’re supposed to add water to, and just drinking it straight. It’s pure comic book madness

      I haven’t been paying too much attention to Man of Steel either. Since DC seems to be trying out the Marvel integrated franchise concept, I hope it’s good, but I’m not going to bet on it. Low expectations mean having a better chance of being impressed, so I’m taking the cautious rout myself.

Leave a Reply

  

  

  


9 − 5 =

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>