Stephen reviews: The Super Dimension Fortress Macross: Do You Remember Love? (1984)

The Super Dimension Fortress Macross: Do You Remember Love? [超時空要塞マクロス 愛・おぼえていますか, Chōjikū Yōsai Makurosu: Ai Oboete Imasu ka] (1984)

AKA Macross: Do You Remember Love?, Super Dimension Fortress Macross the Movie, Macross: Clash of the Bionoids, Super Spacefortress Macross

Starring Mari Iijima, Arihiro Hase, Mika Doi, Akira Kamiya, Osamu Ichikawa, Eiji Kanie, Ryūnosuke Ōbayashi

Directed by Shōji Kawamori & Noboru Ishiguro


Here it is: Macross. The holy grail of sci-fi anime. It may not have as much mainstream recognition as some others, but within the industry, Macross is the preeminent giant robot anime. In America, it was turned into the first part of the Robotech series, one of the more popular cartoon shows of the 80s. It even impacted the Transformers. The character Jetfire was created from a Macross toy, and while Michael Bay and Shia LaBeouf have been using the Transformers franchise as their own personal commode lately, that Macross inspired character is still around today.

There is no Robotech version of this film, which is an adaptation of the original Macross TV series, but because of the various copyright conundrums, it never got a proper American release. It did get an English dub under the title Macross: Clash of the Bionoids, but one version going by that title was edited into oblivion. (If someone makes a list of the most confusingly published movies, this one better be on it.) I didn’t have much trouble getting a DVD of the original Do You Remember Love, but it is an all region disc, so I think it’s an international release that somehow sidestepped the copyright problems. Sadly, that “perfect edition” is far from perfect. While it does have some good quality video, the subtitles are abysmally timed. The worst part is the karaoke subtitles, which cannot be turned off under any circumstances. Maybe someday we’ll get a good remastered Blu-ray edition in America, but don’t hold your breath.

So, while I’ve been blithering about the oddities of publication, you’ve probably been wondering just why the hell a movie about giant robots fighting aliens in space has the title “Do You Remember Love?” The answer is that this is Macross. This is the story of how an ordinary love song saves the human race from extinction. For all its dogfights, swarms of missiles, and huge spaceships, Macross has always, at its heart, been a love story. And while the final climax does have main man Hikaru bust into the room in his giant robot bristling with guns and missiles, he doesn’t do something as boring as crash through a door. No, he flies through a holographic image of leading lady Minmay while she sings “I love you so!”

It’s not often that you see a ferocious battle played out to a gentle love song, and you might expect the two tones to clash, but nothing could be further from the truth. The song becomes an excellent counterpoint to the death and destruction, making that final battle more tragic than exciting, more desperate than triumphant, and it underscores the entire purpose of the story. The simple use of that love song makes the end of the movie more tense and emotional than any fast and hectic tune could have ever done.

If you think this all seems a little melodramatic, well, frankly you’d be right. It is a rather melodramatic concept, but it is also partly because the film is a summary of the events from the TV series. It takes the most climactic and emotional moments of the series and distils them into one movie, intensifying the drama. And it does a superb job of it, breaking the epic tale down to its bare essentials while still retaining a surprising coherence. Kawamori and Ishiguro realized that trying to explain the situation would only be a boring information dump for newcomers, and simply redundant for fans. Besides, how much more explanation do you need than “alien invasion.” Because all the complicated stuff was left out, every scene gets the time it needs to do its job, and you never feel that they were trying to cram in as much as possible at the cost of good pacing.

The romantic moments are savored, perhaps more so than the action scenes, drawing them out so the relationships feel developed and believable. Despite being a good thing, this may be the biggest problem with the film. Action fans will likely find themselves bored by the slow romantic parts, while romance fans will be just as bored during the action sequences. And there are some damn cool action scenes. How many films have a shootout in a pitch dark airlock, lit only by the muzzle flash of the guns? To truly enjoy the film you will need to appreciate both the romance and the combat.

While the plot is focused evenly, the animation is a mixed bag, although on average it is very good, especially for the time period. 1984 was the same year that Nausicaa debuted, soon spawning Studio Ghibli and forever raising the bar on how good an anime could look. It would be silly to expect such great animation from Macross, but there are some moments of just plain lazy animation that give it a B-movie feel at times. However, it also has scattered nuggets of animation gold that even Ghibli would have been proud of, and even at its worst the animation isn’t terrible. Mostly the characters themselves have lower quality animation, while the action sequences get the main focus. This may have something to do with director Shoji Kawamori, who is no stranger to Macross. He was the mechanical designer for the original series, and most, if not all, of its giant robots and alien spaceships were made by him. Perhaps he had a bit of bias for his own creations, and gave them more of the animation budget.

With great moments of animation and an accessible plot for the unfamiliar, fans of space opera should search this one out, as there has rarely been a film that embodies the term so well. Others may not find it as interesting though, and it remains primarily a treat for fans of the original, capturing the most heartwarming, and heartrending, moments of the series with flare and beauty. It’s a great watch for anyone that fondly remembers Robotech, and anyone that likes epic space warfare will also find a lot to love.

2 comments to Stephen reviews: The Super Dimension Fortress Macross: Do You Remember Love? (1984)

  • Always, always have time for Robotech, i do, but the different versions between the US (which we had here in Australia) and the original Japanese always confused me. I always found the Zentradhi (sp?) better villains that I ever did the Invid… just sayin’, from one Robotech/Macross fan to another.

    Nice work, Stephen. I’m gonna have to get online and revisit more of my childhood methinks!

    • Thanks!

      Macross/Robotech definitely has a very confusing history of publication. And I’m sure being in Australia adds another wrinkle or two to the copyright mess. I have to agree with you though. I switched over from Robotech to Macross early on and never really looked back, and the Invid were never in Macross. Most opinions I’ve seen online agree that the original is better. Netfilx had the whole Robotech series on instant play, but I canceled that service when they changed their prices around. It’s something I ought to check out again if I get the opportunity. That opening theme music always gives me a warm fuzzy feeling.

Leave a Reply

  

  

  


− 2 = 5

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>