Stephen reviews: Ninja Scroll (1993)

Ninja Scroll [獣兵衛忍風帖, Jūbē Ninpūchō] (1993)

Starring Kōichi Yamadera, Emi Shinohara, Takeshi Aono, Daisuke Gôri, Toshihiko Seki, Shûichirô Moriyama

Directed by Yoshiaki Kawajiri


Despite the title, Ninja Scroll doesn’t have much in the way of scrolls. There’s only one, and while it is important for a minor plot point, it certainly isn’t title worthy. But if the film doesn’t deliver the kind of ancient literary action that you were hoping for, let me tell you, it certainly keeps its word about the ninjas. In fact, it has so many to spare that it kills off a dozen of them in the first ten minutes. The poor guys don’t even stand a chance, as their opponent is a gigantic ninja made of rock with an equally gigantic two-bladed sword that he hurls around like a boomerang. He’s one of the Eight Demons (or devils, depending on the translation) of Kimon who all have a different magic power. In fact the only major character in the movie that doesn’t have some kind of magic ability is Jubei, the main character, who has only his badass sword skills to keep him alive.

Jubei gets hired, or rather blackmailed, by an old ninja to fight against the demons. And of course, the old man has powers, too. He can stretch into strange shapes and change color like a chameleon. They also wind up working with Kagero, a female ninja with her own power, who helps in order to repay Jubei for saving her from being raped. The sexual content is pretty graphic, so anyone squeamish about the rape scene may be getting more than they bargained for.

Kagero has much in common with another female ninja, Oyuki from The Dagger of Kamui. Both in appearance and personality they are much the same, both even throw flower petals from their sleeves that confuse and distract their opponents. There are actually a lot of similarities between the two films. Both deal with shadowy rebellions that threaten to erupt in civil war, and both have a search for stolen gold. Quite a few plot twists parallel between the two films, but this is more to do with both of them paying homage to the ninja action genre in general, rather than being a blatant copy. Ninja Scroll also features other common samurai story elements not in Kamui, such as the blind swordsman, who’s preternatural hearing makes him better than anyone else, or the opening scene, where Jubei has a showdown while crossing a bridge.

As many similarities as there are with Kamui, the two films have a vastly different style and approach, especially to the combat. While Kamui relies upon imagery and implication for its action scenes, Ninja Scroll is direct and brutal, but always inventive. Every character gets taken out by some clever bit of ingenuity. The fantastical nature of the character’s abilities prevents simple straightforward battles, and some new trick is always necessary take out the villains. The movie mostly focuses on these decisive moments rather than a trade of blows between opponents; any normal combat situations are handled swiftly in order to move on to the next bit of trickery. For instance, at the end of the movie, Jubei must take on a horde of ninjas bounding over the rooftops. But rather than showing us that fight, the scene shifts to the villains plotting their next move amidst the piles of ninjas freshly killed by Jubei, while the clanging and slicing of his continuing battle echoes across the town.

Ninja Scroll is far more of an action film than a drama, and rushes from fight to fight with little time for character development. It doesn’t neglect its characters, though. Their feelings are usually written on their faces during moments between battles. This is truest for Kagero, who copes with her abuses quietly and in private, rather than with words. Even the villains, who have little individual screen time, often have motives and ambitions that set up rivalries among themselves.

Now, any good ninja movie ought to have some skullduggery going on. It’s what ninjas do. And we’ve got plenty of it here. In fact, the last act of the film has as many betrayals as it does action sequences, and the backstabbing doesn’t stop until the credits start. And all of it is managed without being confusing. To an extent at least. To Japanese audiences, it was probably quite easy to follow, but the flurry of Japanese names bounding around was enough to make it hard even for me to tell which team was which, and I’m used to having a lot of Japanese names bouncing around. As long as you can keep track of what the different factions are called, you will have a very twisty plot that remains very navigable. Every turn is foreshadowed and well set up. When one comes along, it feels natural and inevitable. My only problem here is entirely my own. I saw this film years ago, and now that I have matured and gained a finer appreciation of its subtleties, I unfortunately remembered all the plot twists. Coming to this film unaware would have been a treat.

Despite my foreknowledge of the events, I found myself eagerly looking forward to them, and I never tired of the situations or the battle scenes, no matter how much I knew what was coming. Ninja action fans should definitely pick this one up, and I highly recommend martial arts fans of any kind to give it a try, if for no other reason than to see a Japanese fantasy take on the genre.

3 comments to Stephen reviews: Ninja Scroll (1993)

  • It’s easy to see where the Wachowski’s stole a lot of their ideas for filming The Matrix, watching this clip here. I’m not generally a fan of anime or manga, but I recognize cool storytelling when I see it, and I see it here. It does scare me a bit that the words “with little time for character development” are included in any film review, but my hazy memory of this film (and i saw it only the once, late at night at a friends house during celebrations for some milestone birthday I think it was) doesn’t include any of the stuff in this clip. Mebbe I’m thinking of a different film! Oh well.

    nice review, Stephen. I’m gonna have to revisit Ninja Scrolls at some stage.

    • It may not have much time for the characters, but it never wastes the time it gives them. Maybe I’m just action focused as a viewer (OK there’s no maybe about it), but I had a lot of fun with this one.

      I’ve heard The Matrix had a lot of anime influence, and since they made that whole “Animatrix” thing there’s not much denying it. But while your Ninja Scroll memories are vague, my Matrix memories are pretty vague. I haven’t seen that since it came out, so I don’t feel qualified to comment. Maybe I ought to revisit it. My review slated for the 11th is another film that is supposed to be a big influence on The Matrix, too. I’ll follow Will’s lead and leave it a big mystery until then.

      I’m glad you enjoyed the review, and I hope you continue to enjoy the future ones!

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!