I finished the first season of Doctor Who the other day, and while I knew I’d be a fan after just one episode, now my love for the show is firmly entrenched. It’s a unique take on the sci-fi TV show, specifically because it’s more focused on serial-style adventure thrills than truly thought-provoking science fiction (although there is a bit of that, too). I love how the show’s basic premise allows the writers to dream up literally ANYTHING and it’s a plausible setting for the next story. This lends the show an unpredictable nature that makes it really special.
But while it is unpredictable in that regard, the stories themselves do become rather predictable after you’ve seen a few. There’s always some contrived reason why the group can’t just jump in the Tardis and leave danger behind, and over the course of the story it’s not wrong to expect at least one member of the group to get kidnapped (and subsequently rescued). These can easily be seen as faults or examples of lazy writing, but in a weird way these obvious plot points endeared themselves to me over time and I found myself looking forward to seeing how the show would deliver the goods each time.
And this is really my experience with the show in general. There are many reasons why this first season of Doctor Who should not stand the test of time. There are flubbed lines, cameras banging into things and jostling during dolly shots, a very high suspension of disbelief required to overlook some of the stupider moments of logic, etc. There’s also the low-budget 1960s FX work, which will turn off many (but I enjoyed thoroughly), and that distinctly ugly and rather odd look of the ’60s videotape it was shot on. In spite of all of this, the fun of the premise shines through.
It’s wrong to criticize the budget of the production, anyway. It’s easy to laugh at things like the incredibly slow and awkward battle that Ian has with an Aztec warrior atop a pyramid, but I always found myself laughing along with the show instead of at it. Each story has fairly elaborate sets built just for it, as well as lots of good costume work. I appreciate what they were able to achieve instead of focusing on what they weren’t (and this is precisely the key to enjoying any low-budget content).
I don’t know that I’d recommend that everyone should watch the whole season like I did (especially if you don’t care about classic TV or low-budget stuff), but I would say that The Aztecs story (4 episodes) and The Keys of Marinus (6 episodes) are great examples of what the show has to offer. I’ve read elsewhere that The Keys of Marinus is generally not well-regarded, but I loved it. The final story of the season, The Reign of Terror (6 episodes), is also quite good, although only four of the original episodes survive and the remaining two have had their original soundtrack placed over questionable animation. The Daleks (7 episodes) is also of interest for introducing the series’ ultra-villain, but I honestly found that story to be needlessly stretched out. It probably could have been 4–5 solid episodes, but I forgive them as it was only the series’ second storyline.
The first episode is also a notable one to see, as it is quite brilliant in its introduction to the world of Doctor Who. Doctor Who himself doesn’t even appear until halfway through the show! Instead we begin with a pair of teachers, Barbara and Ian. They’re humans with no knowledge of the supernatural goings-on around them, but they are suspicious about the home life of one of their new students, Susan. Susan exhibits great knowledge in some subjects, but is almost totally clueless in others. This investigation soon leads them all down a path of mystery and the adventure of a lifetime!
I also want to mention the theme music, because it is incredible. It’s notable for the time as one of the earliest examples of electronic music. This is something easily overlooked in the current age of nearly complete digital takeover, but if you read about how the theme was painstakingly created, you’ll get a good idea of how much effort went into creating this very memorable, otherworldly science fiction theme. A simple orchestral score would have been much easier, but I can definitely say that the extra work was worth it! The theme is catchy and incredible, and about five seconds into the first time I heard it I was in love.
There’s also a distinct difference in Doctor Who compared to the TV shows of the period from the US. It’s a hard thing to explain, I think, but Doctor Who feels much more low-key and quaint. I haven’t watched a lot of British TV from any era, so maybe their programs are just like this in general. Anyway, there’s far less pomp and circumstance, almost like Doctor Who is a public access cousin to the US network TV shows. The Doctor Who intro is roughly 20 seconds long and features nothing but the show’s title and some trippy graphics. This makes the show more mysterious the first time you see it as you really have no idea what to expect from the intro (other than something in the sci-fi genre). American TV shows of the era were also supported mainly by sponsors, and often had the characters do small promos for these products. I don’t believe that British TV had this sort of relationship with corporations at the time, and it shows. Doctor Who doesn’t feel beholden to anyone; I’m sure there were creative restrictions on the writing staff, but it feels virtually wide open.
And finally, I’d like to mention the character of the Doctor himself. He’s far different than I had imagined him to be. He’s actually not much more than a smart old man with a ship that travels through time and space, at least in this inaugural season. We don’t know why he’s got the ship, we don’t really know much of anything about him or his granddaughter. In a more modern show, character depth would be required but in this style of adventure serial that’s all we need. For this kind of thing, the Doctor’s character is perfect. He’s equal parts kind, aloof grandfather and curmudgeonly old man. It’s an endearing mixture that quickly worms its way into your heart.
It’s interesting to note how different the character was originally, though, in the show’s unaired pilot (which is available on DVD). The actual debut episode is based on the same script as the unaired pilot, with slight alterations, so it makes for a great comparison of how small character changes can affect a work of fiction. In the unaired version, the Doctor is downright mean, not doing much more than yelling at everyone throughout his scenes. He seems like quite the vicious soul, and as I watched I wondered how such a hard-to-like character could spawn a huge cult following. Upon watching the actual debut episode, it all became clear. I imagine that if these changes were not made to the Doctor prior to the show’s airing, we might not have hundreds and hundreds of Doctor Who episodes!
Well, so much for a few quick thoughts! I guess I had a lot more to say than I expected to. In any case, take my geyser of words about this newfound treasure (to me) as a representation of how much I enjoyed it. And feel free to chime in with your thoughts too!
This is a fan-made recreation of what a trailer might have been like, and it’s really well done!