AKA Hell City Shinjuku, Monster City
Starring Hideyuki Hori, Hiromi Tsuru, Kiyoshi Kobayashi, Kyouko Tonguu, Yuusaku Yara, Asami Mukaidono, Ichirō Nagai
Directed by Yoshiaki Kawajiri
The next anime based on Hideyuki Kikuchi novels is directed by Yoshiaki Kawajiri, the same guy that brought us Ninja Scroll. Considering how awesome that film was, I was eagerly looking forward to this one. It certainly has the animation quality to match that later work, which surprised me coming from an ’80s anime, but unfortunately it left me a bit disappointed in other aspects.
The movie starts out strong, with a kick-ass sword fight across the rooftops of Tokyo that ends with the destruction of Shinjuku. (For the confused at this point, Shinjuku is not actually a city. Rather, it is one of the special wards of Tokyo.) Authorities believe it’s a bizarre earthquake, but we know better. That crazy evil guy we just saw was actually summoning demons to take over the world, and now Shinjuku is under their control. Fast forward 10 years, and Shinjuku is now a haunted wasteland filled only with villains, the dregs of humanity, and the demons that hunt them.
The demons on the other hand are just out for blood. The best parts of the film are when the characters are being chased around by them. The action is great and the fluid animation really makes it all come together. There are some beautiful, creepy scenes of the giant spider monster with a mouth in its stomach popping out of walls and other objects, literally passing right through them like a ghost, although there is nothing insubstantial about the destruction it causes as it rampages around.
More so than that, however, is the increasing blandness of the events and situations. Somewhere in the second half, I began drifting from intrigued excitement to attention wandering boredom. Some of this is because the other demons are less creative and interesting than the two I mentioned, but a large part of this is also my dislike of Sayaka. She is very determined to do things, but she is completely incapable of anything. Yet the story plays up her importance despite how little she contributes. I also just didn’t buy it when she defeats a demon by talking to it. Granted, depicting psychological events visually is rather difficult, so maybe this was a scene better left to the novel, but the idea of stopping a raging, incoherent demonic power just by being nice felt rather trite to me.
Somewhere along the way the film loses its sense of climactic grandeur and never gets it back. What really saves it from disaster by the end is its great animation. Even after I had lost interest, I was still watching with admiration as the fluid motion played out. This is especially unusual for an ’80s anime, and while this is from the late ’80s, it has the look and polish that was rare until well into the ’90s. Other well animated films from the decade, like Harmageddon, and especially Macross: Do You Remember Love?, have a jerky feel to the quality, saving their best animation for important scenes while less climactic moments get far less attention. The consistency of Demon City‘s animation puts it into a rare group alongside Akira and Studio Ghibli films. Not that it’s as well animated as those films, but I can’t think of anything else from the ’80s better than Demon City. Possibly Project A-Ko, but not by much.
It’s not a bad film, but it burns itself out in the first half. If the exact same material had been the other way around I probably would have loved it, but when a film ends on a down note it kinda kills the fun of the first half, so I wound up disappointed even though there is a lot of great stuff here. If you can watch a bland ending without it ruining the fun you had earlier, then this is a good film to check out. It left me with a bad aftertaste, however, and others will probably have the same reaction.