Starring Donnie Yen, Leon Lai, Charlie Yeung, Lu Yi, Lau Kar-Leung, Sun Hong-Lei, Kim Soo-Yeon, Michael Wong Man-Tak, Chi Kuan-Chun, Jason Pai Piao, Duncan Lai, Tai Li-Wu, Zhang Jing-Chu, Huang Peng, Ma Jing-Wu
Directed by Tsui Hark
Expectations: Moderate. It seems to have a lot going for it, but I don’t want to get too excited.
Back in my teenage years, Tsui Hark was one of the mystical, incredible directors that I loved. He was responsible for some of the best films Hong Kong had to offer, most notably the Once Upon a Time in China films and Zu Warriors from the Magic Mountain (among many, many others). Like lots of the big Hong Kong directors though, he emigrated over to the US in the late 90s, hoping to find grand success on the larger American stage. Instead, he found heartache and disappointment with a pair of underperforming JCVD films, Double Team and Knock Off. To be fair, I’ve only seen half of Double Team and the first few minutes of Knock Off, something I plan to remedy at some point, but from these small bits one might guess he had lost his knack for filmmaking. Seven Swords is a few years later, but it proves why Hong Kong filmmakers should stay in Hong Kong (unless an American studio is willing to give them free rein, which is never going to happen).
On the surface, Seven Swords is yet another play on the Seven Samurai framework. A helpless village is being assaulted by bandits and they need the help of seven rogue swordsman and all that. Here it’s slightly tweaked where the Emperor has sent out an edict where all practitioners of martial arts are to be killed. General Fire-Wind and his brutal army are parading around the land, killing and beheading whoever fits the bill. They happen upon a remote village and quickly plan their assault. Two of the villagers, along with veteran martial arts choreographer and all-around Hong Kong legend Lau Kar-Leung, venture out to Mount Heaven in search of some help from the hermit swordsmen residing there. So yeah, the setup is very Seven Samurai, but the rest of the movie is anything but.
What’s the most frustrating about Seven Swords, though, is that it was made in 2005. Due to this, it suffers, as most HK films of the era do, from trying to feel closer to a Western-produced film. The editing here is at time very questionable, and there’s a ridiculous overuse of closeups during the action scenes which obscures a lot of the great choreography. If only this had been made at Hong Kong’s height, the late 80s/early 90s, then we’d see the full potential of a movie about seven badass swordsmen from Mount Heaven with seven badass swords facing off against a horde of devious villains with warpaint and equally devious weapons. To simply dream of what might have been is missing the point that this Seven Swords, the only one that truly exists, is pretty damn good.
It’s also a mistake to think of Seven Swords as an action film; it’s much closer to a new entry in the traditional Chinese wuxia genre that also features some action. It’s very similar to a lot of the early Shaw Brothers pictures in this regard, where the focus was always on the drama over the minutia of the fights, so this can easily derail an action fan looking for ass-kicking fighters to start kicking ass. In this day and age, this has to be a hard film to market, as going this route might win points at an international art film festival, but most Western audiences only want to see Hong Kong action films.
The acting is uniformly great from the entire cast, and what a cast it is! Donnie Yen is great, of course, but he’s honestly not in the movie all that much. Seven Swords is much more of an ensemble movie without any real main characters, and while Yen is regarded as the top swordsman of the group, he hangs back mostly and lets Lau Kar-Leung lead the way. You’ve also got Leon Lai and Charlie Yeung, adding some 90s HK star power to the bunch, and let’s not forget that Chi Kuan-Chun, star of many 70s Shaw Brothers films including Men from the Monastery, makes a rare appearance here as Dongluo.
But yeah, Lau Kar-Leung! I love him so much and it was his involvement that got me to stop procrastinating and watch this film. After the 90s, Lau pretty much retired from the film business, so anytime he does something it’s cause for celebration. He was responsible for so much of the amazing choreography that helped create and define the martial arts genre at the Shaw Brothers studio and he’s one of my absolute favorites. He was also a fantastic director creating some of the most iconic films the genre has to offer. Little films like The 36th Chamber of Shaolin, Challenge of the Masters or Drunken Master II. He’s also a wonderful screen actor and Seven Swords allows him to give it all one more try. He’s in the movie a lot more than I expected him to be as well.
Seven Swords may start out on a Seven Samurai framework, but it develops into much more than that over the course of the film. I overlooked this one for a long time because I thought it was nothing more than a Chinese re-telling of the tale, but I’m glad I finally watched it. It’s actually more of a Chinese fantasy & swordplay wuxia film and I thoroughly enjoyed it. If you go in with the proper expectations, I think any Tsui Hark fan could get a great time out of this one.