Directed by Peter Jackson
Expectations: High. I love this.
Can I give this one five stars? It took 10 years and more than a few re-watches, but I have finally come around on this one. Don’t get me wrong, I always loved the film, but I also always thought it was the weakest of the trilogy. This time I was struck by how powerful a film Return of the King is, and how well it brings everything set forth in the previous films together. But what this recent change of heart proves to me is that there is no truly standout film from the others. They are all interdependent and equal in their greatness, and I will most likely shift allegiances between the three throughout my lifetime.
Opening with Gollum’s backstory provides us with a glimpse of how he became the creature we’re familiar with, and it also allows the film to open in the quiet green of the Hobbit lands. The Two Towers ends with a lengthy battle sequence at night, finishing a film that contains trial after trial for our fellowship. So to begin the next film in a peaceful, happy place (if only for a few moments) is surprising and brilliant. It reminds us a bit of what the hobbits are fighting for, and shows us the depths of despair, all within that first scene. It also skillfully leads us right back into the thick of things where we can finally reckon with the one ring and finish the journey once and for all.
I always knew that Lord of the Rings was an allegory for Tolkien’s experiences in World War I, but never has this aspect jumped out at me with such veracity. The hobbits are our surrogates in this War of the Ring, they are the everyman drafted into the infantry to fight a war that doesn’t directly affect them at this point. But no matter what circumstances they find themselves in, the hobbits persevere, and are often more courageous and valiant than any of their full-size friends. Their bonds of friendship are tight and unbreakable, and they teach the men who seem bred for this type of warring life more than a few things about what it means to fight, struggle and sacrifice for their country.
I’ve managed to get through my reviews of this series without once mentioning one of my most favorite aspects: Howard Shore’s incredible score. Much like any great film score that synchs up flawlessly with the images (such as Star Wars or 2001: A Space Odyssey), Shore’s work on Lord of the Rings is without equal. Easily my pick for the best film music of the entire decade, his amazing themes are skillfully woven together to create a perfect aural representation of the images on-screen. But it was a quick moment towards the end of this film that sparked this paragraph. While Frodo stumbles up Mt. Doom and Jackson captures his anguish in tight close-ups of rock and fist and dirt, Shore goes the opposite direction and inserts a light, almost happy flute to represent everything this moment is about. The hobbits left home to protect their happy way of life, and this is what Frodo must hold onto to keep moving. It’s an incredible moment that sums up the entire drive of the trilogy in a few hopeful notes.
Peter Jackson’s FX background allowed him to work wonders on the Lord of the Rings trilogy, and it continues to stand tall as the crowning achievement in fantasy filmmaking; I wonder if anyone will ever top these films. At least for now, there’s no one even trying, and I think that says a lot about how well-made this trilogy is. The Lord of the Rings is truly classic cinema.