The Muppets Take Manhattan (1984)

Starring Jim Henson, Frank Oz, Dave Goelz, Steve Whitmire, Richard Hunt, Jerry Nelson, Juliana Donald, Lonny Price, Louis Zorich

Directed by Frank Oz

Expectations: Moderate. This was the one I thought was slow and not that good when I was a kid.

Of all the Muppet movies, I was looking forward to re-watching this one the least. It was always my least favorite of the trilogy, and I’ve seen a lot of negativity around it on the Internet (I know… surprising that you’d find negativity on the Internet). My fears were allayed almost immediately after the film began, though, as I was quickly wrapped up in the storyline and the way it unfolded before me. Because I was just a little indifferent to this one as a kid, I’ve seen it the least (which is still probably somewhere in the neighborhood of 20+ watches), so I also remembered the least about it before it started. As it rolled along, I found that I remembered everything in it, and the greatest thing about that was that as each scene came up, I remembered it fondly.

The film opens with Kermit and company performing their musical, Manhattan Melodies, in their college’s auditorium. They’ve put on the show as their senior project and are now recent graduates looking to put their stamp on that big, wide world around them. With stars in their eyes, and the supportive college audience cheering them on, they set out for Broadway. But when they get there, they discover that they aren’t the hot fire they thought they were, and their efforts are met with frustration, despair and heartache.

Where The Muppet Movie was about Kermit the dreamer, and The Great Muppet Caper was a fantasy of sorts, The Muppets Take Manhattan presents the cold, hard reality of failure. The Muppets who could once do anything they desired on film, are now told “No!” relentlessly as they try to get their joyous show on Broadway. This is the only film of the three that doesn’t acknowledge itself as a movie, and as such it presents a genuine story arc that the other films don’t have. Without that constant wink and a nod, The Muppets Take Manhattan is able to transcend being just another great Muppet movie, and is simply a great movie.

I realize that part of my love is nostalgia, but it’s also that finally after 20 years I’m able to appreciate this film that I always liked but never truly loved. The Muppets Take Manhattan also feels like it’s aimed at adults more than the prior two films. I was never able to completely comprehend everything going on as a child, and all that sadness really bummed me out. But this time around, it worked oppositely on me, as I saw it for what it was: classic screenwriting.

If you’d like to watch movies without knowing why they do the things they do, I suggest you skip to the next paragraph. After I learned this next factoid, I was unable to unlearn it, and now I’m cursed to recognize it in hundreds and hundreds of movies. Sometimes, such as in the case of The Muppets Take Manhattan, it increases my enjoyment because I feel that understanding the workings gives me a more fully realized appreciation of the payoff. In modern romantic comedies, though, it’s not so perfect and whenever the script reaches this point, I always do a big eye roll and say, “Number Nine.” So if you’re content with not knowing, please skip ahead. OK, for those still here: “Number Nine” refers to a point in the script where it feels like we’re building up to the climax, but then the rug is pulled out from under the characters and now they’re at a lower point than they’ve ever been. It’s the “Oh, how will we ever recover from this?” point, and if you’re following the general screenwriting formula for a 120 minute film, it comes around minute 90, or point #9 on your outline. At least, this was how I learned it.

Technically, the film is just as impressive as the previous films, if not more. Henson’s ability to bring these characters to life in real-world situations is incredible, and I don’t know that I’ve seen anything like it before or since. Henson was truly a special guy, and I hope that the new films don’t end up overwhelming his greatness for the majority of the population that didn’t grow up with these original works. I’m sad to say that I think that’s the case, what with all the raves that The Muppets received, all the while being a far inferior film.

The Muppets Take Manhattan is a great addition to the pantheon of Muppet cinema, and I’m so glad to have re-watched it. The songs are catchy, and I loved them just as much as I did as a kid, even if they are kinda Broadway. At least it makes sense here, as the whole film revolves around the iconic street. It’s a sad one, though, and much more emotionally charged than either of the previous films, which may or may not be a good thing depending on the person/kid. But the sadness allows for some of the Muppets’ most inventive and imaginative moments, as the gang is split up for a good portion of the film. They keep up with Kermit by sending him letters and postcards, and we get to witness these hilarious adventures first-hand. And on top of all that, the finale of the film is a show within a show, reminding me in ways of the similar device in The Red Shoes, and this elevates the film’s emotional heart to such a high, that it validates all the time we spent down in the dumps with Kermit trying to get the show off the ground. I loved The Muppets Take Manhattan, and if you end up watching (or re-watching) it, I hope you do too.

6 comments to The Muppets Take Manhattan (1984)

  • This was my least-favorite of the trilogy growing up as well… and in all honesty I have to say it still is. I can appreciate it more as an adult, and it’s still a very good film, but it doesn’t resonate with me as much as the others. An ode to Broadway doesn’t work so well for someone who isn’t a big Broadway fan, right? And in a lot of ways it didn’t feel as much like a Muppet movie as the others did… it doesn’t have as much of the trademark wackiness, reduced in favor of the Broadway schmaltz. Plus I have trouble forgiving it for introducing the Muppet Babies. Ack.

    Still, it’s well made, it has its fun moments, and “You Can’t Take No For an Answer” is a great song.

    • Hahaha, I grew up watching tons of Muppet Babies so I don’t mind that part at all. I can totally understand where you’re coming from, but I like that scene a lot. Baby Rowlf is so funny at the piano. I agree that it has a different feel, and lot of that is due to the Broadway setting, but I think it works really well here. I’m not a Broadway fan either, so my love for this one is purely on a film/story basis. It isn’t quite as wacky, but it feels more like a real movie and I really like that they were able to pull that off.

  • Embarrassed to say that I’ve never seen any of the Muppet films (except for the new one). I’m sure I saw snippets of them growing up but I don’t remember seeing any of them start to finish. I’ll have to fix this.

    • Oh man, I have no idea how they’d play to a newcomer, but I’d guess they wouldn’t make quite the same impact. I much prefer these originals to the new movie, as they are completely different. To me, these three movies are what the Muppets are all about, so I had hoped the new one would recapture that glory.

  • This is easily my favorite Muppet film, probably followed by A Christmas Carol and the recent Jason Segal version. Love it. Love it. Even the cameos, most of whom I have no idea who they are (although there’s a few good ones) still make me giggle.

    What do you think Gill?
    Oh, I don’t know Jill, what about you Bill?
    Sounds good Gill.

    Classic Muppets.

Leave a Reply to Will Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.