The Descendants (2011)

Starring George Clooney, Shailene Woodley, Beau Bridges, Judy Greer, Nick Krause, Amara Miller, Matthew Lillard, Robert Forster, Patricia Hastie, Mary Birdsong, Rob Huebel, Milt Kogan, Laird Hamilton, Michael Ontkean, Matt Corboy, Celia Kenney

Directed by Alexander Payne

Expectations: High, but guarded. Trailer looked boring.


The Descendants is the type of movie I would never actively go out to see in theaters. Not only were the trailers uninteresting, from what I heard of the story it didn’t sound like it would resonate with me. Within this thought lies my wrongdoing, because not only did The Descendants resonate, the issues it deals with transcend the plot specifics of the film and work on a deep, human level. The Descendants also trades in witty, off-beat comedy and by bringing these two disparate elements together, it creates an excellent window into real life. It’s still a Hollywood-produced film so it’s not truly realistic, but the emotions expressed are real and palpable throughout the film.

The Descendants tells the story of Matt King (George Clooney) and his family’s struggle to deal with his wife Elizabeth’s boating accident. It has left her in a coma, with limited chance of survival, and Matt is having a hard time coming to terms with what that means for his life. Caring for their two daughters has always fallen on Elizabeth, so the thought of having to raise his daughters alone frightens him.

Director Alexander Payne is known for bringing intensely good writing to the screen, and The Descendants might be his best work yet. I certainly liked it more than his other films that I’ve seen (Election, About Schmidt, & Sideways), and I liked all of those pretty well. His visuals aren’t particularly artistic or flashy, but his films have an unmistakable style that feels cohesive. This style comes out most in the writing — specifically in the way the characters speak to each other — instead of the visuals, and in a primarily visual medium, that’s pretty interesting.

But there are perfect moments in this film that capture the sadness and pain of losing someone, and they are all directly influenced by Payne’s choices with the camera. The first is when Matt informs his oldest daughter of his wife’s situation while she casually swims in their pool. Instead of continuing the dialogue exchange, or focusing on her outburst, she submerges her head underwater and the camera follows. The outer world blocked out, the only thing that remains is her emotional face and the heartbreaking pain. Another similar moment comes towards the end of the film, and Payne’s choice of a tight close-up on a couple of faces punctuates and exaggerates the emotions we’ve felt throughout the film. It’s moments like these that set the great directors apart from the flock, and Payne proves once again — subtly — that he’s the real deal.

There’s also the choice to never show a flashback of Matt’s wife while she was living and breathing normally. Her character is confined to the coma and her hospital bed throughout, acting as something of a lightning rod, drawing people and energies toward her. Everything we know about her comes from the actions and interactions of the other characters, and as funny as it might be to say it, Elizabeth ends up being one of the most well-developed characters in the film.

The Descendants isn’t the type of movie you’ll want to re-watch again and again, but it is a fantastic piece of work. Perfectly acted by the entire cast — yes, even Matthew Lillard! — and expertly directed by Alexander Payne, The Descendants is truly one of the best films of 2011. It’s not a flashy movie, but it deals solely in deep, resonant dramatic situations brought to life by excellent, tragically comic writing. Laughing through tears is a great, liberating feeling, and The Descendants captures it beautifully.

10 comments to The Descendants (2011)

  • Great review! It came out over here this year and absolutely loved it. Will end up in my best of list of 2012.

  • Good review Will. The characters and dialogue are very rich, but my only problem was with the pacing. Sometimes it would pick-up, other times, it would just seem to linger and lag on without any real motivation whatsoever. Still, Clooney and everybody else was just great.

    • I can understand why you’re saying about the pacing, but I didn’t have that problem with the film much at all. But it definitely has a groove to get into if you want to enjoy it fully.

  • Great review, Will…. I always look forward to the more mainstream reviews you write! I haven’t seen this yet (although it’s on the list) but I will say that I’m expecting to enjoy it simply becase my wife didn’t. Her opinion on film isn’t something I value highly, truth be told – mainly because she doesn’t like the same stuff I do, and loves things like Twilight. Anyway, I’m holding out hope that I’ll enjoy it as much as you did – and my review will undoubtedly link back here when I post one.

    • Thanks, Rodney! It mean a lot that you look forward to the mainstream reviews. I’m trying to do more of them than I used to, but I always get pulled away to things that are more exciting to me (like Hong Kong movies or horror or something). One of these days I’ll get out to the theater regularly!

      Looking forward to your eventual review and I do hope you enjoy it as much as I did. My girlfriend loved it, but a few of my coworkers thought it was boring and didn’t get why it was so acclaimed. I guess among the regular folk the opinion is not as one-sided like the critics.

  • I did happen to see this film in theaters. Chiefly because SIDEWAYS has become one of my favorite films, and thus anything Payne creates, I’ll see.

    Glad you felt so strongly about this one. While the feeling is rare, laughing and crying is a mix not often conveyed in the movies.

    Well stated Will. Keep up the good work.

  • Spot on review sir. I’ve seen this twice now, and it never really jumps out while watching it, but when the film has finished it hits you like a brick wall. After seeing it in the cinema I sat in my car for about 10 mins doing nothing, just contemplating how great a film it was, and clearing my head.

    Great direction and stunning performances from Clooney and the older daughter in particular. That last shot too, just great.

Leave a Reply! Comments are always much appreciated!